Bethlehem Homes for Sale

Welcome to the enchanting city of Bethlehem, Connecticut, a hidden gem nestled in the picturesque Litchfield County. Known for its charming New England ambiance, Bethlehem is a community that seamlessly blends rural tranquility with modern conveniences. With a population of just over 3,000 residents, this quaint town offers a close-knit atmosphere, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle.

Bethlehem is rich in history and natural beauty, boasting stunning landscapes, rolling hills, and lush greenery. The town is home to several parks and nature reserves, providing ample opportunities for outdoor activities such as hiking, birdwatching, and picnicking. The annual Bethlehem Fair is a beloved community event that showcases local agriculture, crafts, and entertainment, drawing visitors from near and far.

For those looking to make Bethlehem their home, a variety of homes for sale await. From charming colonial houses with classic architecture to modern ranch-style homes, there’s something to suit every taste and budget. Many properties are set on spacious lots, offering privacy and the chance to enjoy the serene surroundings. With a strong sense of community, excellent schools, and convenient access to nearby towns, Bethlehem is not just a place to live—it’s a place to thrive.

Explore the diverse real estate options available in Bethlehem today and discover why so many people are choosing to call this delightful town home. Whether you’re seeking a peaceful retreat or a vibrant community, Bethlehem welcomes you with open arms!

Newest Bethlehem Homes for Sale

$820,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24194494 MLS

A custom made house built in 1984 by its original owners, made even better by the current owners. Located in the heart of the hills of Litchfield County, you will love this 4 bedroom, 3 full bath home in a completely private setting, situated on professionally landscaped 2.25 acres. The main level includes a family room with french pocket doors, a living room with a stone wall wood burning fireplace, corner bedroom, kitchen with granite counters and roomy cabinetry/dining area plus two full baths with laundry and a four season sunroom. The upstairs level consists of a 16 x 18 primary bedroom and office with charming seating area that looks over the private setting. Two additional bedrooms over the family room provide additional space for the whole family. The in-ground heated pool located just steps away from the house is a retreat for young and old alike. The basement with its large storage area, mechanicals and double door access to a two car garage is any crafts persons dream. Additional great sustainable features include passive heating from the sunroom and a whole house generators. Minutes from the towns of Washington, Roxbury, Woodbury and Litchfield. 90 miles to New York City. 3 hours to Boston. Country living at its best!

35 Nettleton Hollow Rd, Bethlehem

$1,076,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24193014 MLS

Rare Bethlehem Offering - 1740s Antique + Commercial-Ready Barn on 2 Acres Welcome to a rare offering in the heart of Bethlehem, CT, sited at the town's famous blinking light with easy proximity to Washington, Litchfield & Woodbury. Dating to the 1740s, this sensitively preserved 4-bedroom antique is rich with period charm - 5 fireplaces, including a 12' hearth housing a beehive oven, historic detailing, a walk-up attic, and a basement with soaring 9' ceilings. Thoughtful updates throughout make it a warm, move-in-ready home. The real story here is the barn: a striking 3,000 SF structure originally restored for a commercial dine in bakery, with the significant investment already behind it - new roof, doors meeting fire & code, 4-phase electrical, roughed plumbing & HVAC, and poured concrete floors. Reimagine it as an event space, artisan workshop, wellness retreat, or second residence - the foundation is already in place. A picturesque pond adds ambiance, ideal for commercial use or connecting the structures for potential multi-generational living. A charming milk house offers even more flexible space - guest quarters, studio, gym, or workshop. Grounds feature ornamental Japanese & red maples, flowering pear, cherry, birch & magnolia, plus a newly graded and re-graveled driveway (2023) and 75 feet of town-maintained sidewalk! A rare chance to own a piece of Bethlehem's history - the work is already done.

18 East St, Bethlehem

$849,999

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24189999 MLS

Timeless New England Estate with Pond, Barns and 11.9 Scenic Acres Discover the perfect blend of historic charm, natural beauty, and modern comfort at this exceptional 11.9-acre estate in Bethlehem. At its heart is a historic sea captain's home, originally built in Mystic and thoughtfully relocated in 1961. Rich in character and architectural details, the residence has been enhanced with modern updates, including a newer roof and mechanical systems, while preserving its timeless craftsmanship. The home features three spacious bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms, including a serene primary suite complete with a fireplace and private bath. Original paneled living and dining rooms showcase exquisite built-in cabinetry, corner hutches, wide pine flooring, original interior doors, and three working wood-burning fireplaces that create warmth and historic charm throughout. Outside, the property's breathtaking landscape offers open meadows, wooded walking trails, and professionally maintained gardens supported by a full irrigation system and two wells. A spring-fed koi pond serves as a private retreat, complete with a sandy beach, dock, and a custom-built outdoor kitchen pavilion crafted from timber harvested directly from the property. Equipped with electricity, a working sink, and a water tank, the pavilion provides an exceptional setting for outdoor entertaining.

208 Wood Creek Rd, Bethlehem

$649,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24186849 MLS

*SELLER WILLING TO OFFER CONCESSIONS AT CLOSING* Set on 1.5 acres in the heart of Bethlehem, this well-maintained home features vaulted ceilings, a cozy fireplace, custom built-in bookcases, and an open, welcoming layout. The kitchen includes granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, ample cabinetry, and convenient access to the dining area. Main-level laundry adds everyday ease. The finished lower level provides exceptional flexibility with a spacious recreation room, fitness area, full bath, and abundant storage-ideal for a home office, hobbies, guests, or additional living space. Recent improvements include a new roof (2024), luxury vinyl plank flooring, and a new pressurized bladder tank (2025). Enjoy the peaceful outdoor setting from the deck and gazebo, perfect for entertaining, dining, or relaxing. Located in scenic Litchfield County, you'll enjoy easy access to hiking trails, lakes, parks, pickleball and tennis courts, as well as the shops, restaurants, and attractions of nearby Woodbury, Litchfield, Washington, and Watertown. A rare opportunity to enjoy peaceful country living with modern conveniences in one of Connecticut's most desirable areas. *SELLER WILLING TO OFFER CONCESSIONS AT CLOSING*

219 Wood Creek Rd, Bethlehem

$2,150,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24179730 MLS

Discover a rare estate-quality property in the heart of Litchfield County, where timeless character, modern refinement, and more than 40 acres of exceptional natural beauty create an unparalleled retreat. A long private drive winds through rolling landscapes to a thoughtfully reimagined five-bedroom, three-bath residence that seamlessly blends sophisticated updates with the warmth and authenticity of its original design. Expansive windows fill the home with natural light and frame picturesque views. The remarkable grounds feature open meadows, mature pines and hemlocks, historic stone walls, fruit trees, curated gardens, and a tranquil pond, offering unmatched privacy and serenity. Equestrians will appreciate groomed riding trails and ample space for future rings, arenas, or barns. Outdoor enthusiasts will enjoy a 200-yd shooting range, hunting areas, and miles of trails for hiking, biking, ATV adventures, and recreation. Designed for entertaining, the pavilion and patio with a grand stone fireplace provides an unforgettable setting for gatherings and quiet evenings alike. Above the garage, a well appointed guest suite with a living area, kitchenette, and full bath offers flexibility for guests, or an au pair. Conveniently located just 15 minutes from the charming centers of Woodbury, Washington, and Litchfield, and approx two hours from New York City, 119 Judge Lane is a one-of-a-kind legacy estate awaiting its next generational steward.

119 Judge Ln, Bethlehem

$680,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24179254 MLS

Relax by your pool in complete privacy, just minutes from the town center and only 15 minutes to neighboring towns like Woodbury, Washington, Litchfield, and Watertown. This legal two-family home features a spacious studio apartment with a large kitchen and private entrance. Designed by the original owner, a NY designer, the home is beautifully appointed with unique details throughout. A welcoming foyer opens to a large formal living room with a fireplace, flowing into the country kitchen and a cozy den with a wood-trimmed vaulted ceiling. Perfect for entertaining, with access from the den and French doors from the large dining room leading to the mahogany deck and heated gunite pool. The primary bedroom includes a spacious private sitting room, and all rooms are generously sized.

49 Guilds Hollow Rd, Bethlehem

$679,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24177454 MLS

SOLAR PANELS ARE PAID FOR = $9.62 month elec bill!!! Solid, attractive Cape plus newer 2.5 bay detached garage with enormous office and 1/2 bath above. So much potential here - work from home, owners have run a florist business out of first floor of det garage and grew alot of the flowers right in the level back meadow. Or multi generational living would be easy. Bring the animals and have your own farm! The home has a brand-new (6/26) roof, owned solar panels = $9.62 a mos electric bill! Primary suite plus additional bedroom / den w sunny bay window on main level. Kitchen and baths have been updated, formal living room with propane FP and bay window, the room to gather in is the sunroom w light wood walls & ceiling- a cozy propane stove and just off the huge eatin kitchen. LL is finished and could easily be an in-law studio with a full bath and sliders to the patio. Plumbing already there for kitchenette. Office over garage has large 1/2 bath and wet bar. Potential for full bath and kitchen. Furnace 3 years young, new water tank and full generator hook up. This is the house known for the gorgeous flower cart in front yard! Finish gardening (green house, shed, fruit trees, garden beds) play horseshoes, sit by the fire pit, or put your toes in East Spring Brook which runs the back boundry. Short walk to Nonnewaug Falls for a little hike that packs a punch. Alot to offer on this property.

494 Nonnewaug Rd, Bethlehem

$740,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24171289 MLS

UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY WITH MULTIPLE POSSIBILITIES!!! Located in the classic New England town of Bethlehem on 8.5+ acres this is your opportunity for unlimited potential. Build your own Private Estate, Family Compound, Multi-Family Investment, Business Operations with Offices and Storage, Horse Property, Farm and Possible Residential Development. There are two Residential homes and additional structures that can be re-fit to meet your needs. Existing Structures: Primary Residence - 1,876sf with 3 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms; Second Home - 1,100sf with 2 Bedrooms and 1 Bathroom and a 3 Car Garage with a Half-Bathroom. Two additional buildings for storage, hobbies, cars, boats, and all the toys you can fit. Current Use: the owner lives on the property and operates a pet rescue business and the existing Kennels can be very easily removed. There have been many upgrades to all structures on the property.

202 Crane Hollow Rd, Bethlehem

$699,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ ACTIVE Status ⋅ 24139265 MLS

This authentic antique home is ideally located on one of Bethlehem's most desirable country roads, surrounded by other elegant historic properties. Meticulously maintained, it showcases true period charm with spacious rooms, high ceilings, original wide-board floors throughout, and a grand central chimney serving three fireplaces. The main level is perfect for both daily living and entertaining, featuring a large eat-in kitchen, a cozy wood-paneled study with built-in bookcases and fireplace, an inviting living room with fireplace, and a gracious formal dining room-all generously proportioned for comfortable gatherings. Upstairs you'll find three well-sized bedrooms, a full bathroom, a large walk-in attic over the kitchen that's already framed and ready to become a luxurious primary suite, plus a separate walk-up attic with plenty of headroom for additional finished space. The beautifully landscaped grounds include a sweeping level lawn, a fully approved extra building lot with its own private driveway, and a handsome post-and-beam barn offering ample room for vehicles, workshop space, and storage. Move right in and enjoy this classic beauty as-is, or take advantage of the rare opportunity to expand, add a guest house, or create a family compound.

114 Carmel Hill Rd N, Bethlehem

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2026 SmartMLS, Inc.